I don’t like Nazis. I am not subtle about this. I have written quite a lot on the pages of Freedom and Reason about my loathing of Nazis. I confess: I am an anti-Nazi bigot. Obnoxiously so.
I would find it strange if a social media user reported my anti-Nazi posts to my employer. It would suggest that he is a Nazi sympathizer. It would also signal that he is rather ignorant of a widespread prejudice against Nazis in academia—indeed, among the general population.
I would find it stranger still if my employer were to take the matter seriously. I am confident that employer dislikes Nazis as much as I do. I certainly hope that is true. It would be troubling of the university didn’t.
Yet I can imagine a social media user reporting my anti-Muslim posts to my employer—and my employer taking the matter seriously. I would hope they wouldn’t, but given the degree of Islamophilia in academia, it is a possibility.
I say this because I perceive a double standard. I’m guessing some of my readers have the same perception. The accusation of Islamophobia—a propaganda term invented by Muslims to stifle criticisms of Islam—is widely accepted as a legitimate one. It would be nice to chalk up the double standard to ignorance of reason and principle. However, given America’s embrace of Muslims, I don’t think ignorance explain its.
However, supposing ignorance does explain the double standard, I thought it would be helpful to educate the public about why anti-Muslim bigotry is as rational as anti-Nazi prejudice. In this essay, I will show why the double standard violates reason and principle, and this requires showing that there is little light between Islam and National Socialism.
I should begin with why I condemn Nazis in social media posts. The reason is straightforward: Nazis are hateful and dangerous people. While most Nazis are nonviolent, they bear an ideology that is hateful, and this makes them hateful people, and hatefulness makes violence more likely, especially if their numbers grow. Nazis are hateful because they antisemitic, loathe homosexuality, and believe women are properly subordinated to men. Those are good reasons to condemn them.
On this last point, as I wrote in my entry on “Tyranny and Dictatorship” in the Encyclopedia of Men and Masculinities: “The intersection of prescribed gender role and political-military tyranny is readily found in fascist dictatorships.” The Nazi ideal of womanhood is captured by the slogan “Kinder, Küche, Kirche,” which translated to “children, kitchen, church.”
The point is that Nazism is a condemnable worldview. Therefore, those who subscribe to it are condemnable people. It is rational to fuse the two. Without Nazis, there is no Nazism. Without Nazis, Nazism becomes a dead ideology of historical interest, but one without any clear and present danger.
Nazism is not the only ideology with these characteristics, as implied above. The features of Nazism I have identified also lie at the core of Islamic belief, a much older ideological system. Like Nazis, Muslims are antisemitic, loathe homosexuality, and women in Islam are subordinated to men, their gender roles prescribed by Islam, rules enforced by men. This is why Hitler admired Muslims, as did Goebbels. The Nazis allied with Muslims during WWII because they shared very similar worldviews. Nazism and Islam are birds of a feather.
At the same time, like Nazis, most Muslims are nonviolent. However, Muslims subscribe to an ideology that is hateful, and this makes them hateful people. Why we don’t regard these worldviews in the same way is a double standard.
The claim that most Muslims are peaceful is a rationalization that the left would never apply to Nazis. They are aware that, when Nazi violence does occur, the nonviolent Nazis do not condemn it. Either the Nazi remains silent or he blames the victim, who is thought to have in some way or another brought the violence upon himself. They also know that Nazi violence is motivated by the Nazi worldview, and, moreover, when Nazism is ascendent, the nonviolent among them are likely to become violent. This is why we criticize Nazis—to keep them at bay.
It is difficult for progressives to grasp this, but the same is true with Islam. When a Muslim acts violently, Islam is not blamed. Indeed, we are told not to blame Islam or risk being accused of anti-Muslim prejudice. We’re reminded as if we didn’t know that not all Muslims are violent. We are also often told that that Muslim violence is a response to Islamophobia. The Muslim and his apologist blame the victims of violence for doing things that caused the Muslim to act in the way he did.
We see this in the progressive’s support for Jihad against Israel. Israel is the aggressor and the Muslim is only doing what the victims of aggression often do: strike back at their aggressor. They are freedom fighters; Iran, Hamas, and Hezbollah are the Axis of Resistance. More generally, the Muslim is defending his religion in the same way a Nazi defends his ideology. Had the cartoonists at Charlie Hebdo not disrespected Muhammad, they would still be alive. Yet, while it is wrong when the Nazi does it, the Muslim is to be excused for the same action.
For progressives, Nazi are to be blamed for the violence they perpetrate. But instead of blaming Muslims for the violence they perpetrate, many Western governments target non-Muslims for being critical of Islam, justifying state action either because one should not cause offense for dignity’s sake, or on grounds that, if opinions offensive to Muslims are suppressed, there would be less Islamic violence. Great Britain has become notorious for policing speech for these reasons. In this way, these governments positively sanction Islamic terrorism, the goal of which is to silence opposition to Islam.
When governments take the side of Muslims, they become fellow travelers of a militant political movement that is practically indistinguishable to Nazism. This double standard should be obvious. But it is not. Many Brits sense that they’re losing their country to Islam. And they’re not wrong about that.
The classic argument one is given when his speech is deemed anti-Muslim is that it is irrational to judge an entire group based on the behavior of an individual or a small group of individuals—except if the group is designated as Nazi. Moreover, we’re told that there is a distinction between judging people for belonging to a group and judging them for subscribing to an ideology—except for Nazis. However, upon closer examination these are both incoherent positions. They function as thought-stopping devices.
If I condemn Nazism because of the content of its worldview—its antisemitism, authoritarianism, homophobia, misogyny, racism, etc.—then I should apply the same standard to other ideological systems, including religion. After all, religions are idea systems just like political ideologies, and nobody can rationally claim that some ideologies are off limits to criticism or even condemnation.
This extends to those who subscribe to ideologies. A man who subscribes to an ideology becomes the concrete manifestation of the ideology. The man whose identity is a Nazi one cannot be separated from Nazism. He is Nazism. And we are free to condemn him because he subscribes to a condemnable ideology. Likewise, the man who identifies as a Muslim cannot be separated from Islam. The Muslim is Islam. But we are told that we are not free to condemn the Muslim.
You can expect the individual attempting to wriggle out of double standard will draw a distinction between chosen ideologies and those to which the man is born into. But the fact that a worldview is inherited through socialization rather than consciously chosen does not make its underlying propositions immune from intellectual or moral criticism. Suppose Hitler had prevailed and an entire generation of Germans had been raised from birth to be Nazis. Would this make Nazism acceptable? Of course not. Such a situation would only amplify the reason why we went to war with Nazis.
One might also expect this objection: Islam is a religion. But the appeal to divine authority, sacred texts, or transcendent truth confer no special moral immunity. To suggest otherwise would be a form of special pleading. All ideas are subject to criticism, whether they are acquired at birth or acquired later on. A democratic state can take no side on the matter. Not legitimately, anyway.
It follows that all those who subscribe to those ideas are subject to criticism, even condemnation. Many people are born into families that socialize their children to be bigots. Does the bigot get to avoid criticism for his bigotry by claiming he was raised that way? Or does society attempt to educate him out of his irrational prejudices—and condemn him for his stubborn adherence to them? I think you know the answer to that question.
I want to empathize this point, because it goes routinely unacknowledged. It does not matter one whit that Muslims appeal to the authority of God to justify their beliefs. The appeal to a transcendent truth grants a man no immunity from condemnation. After all, Nazism is more than mere political ideology. Hitler appealed to the authority of Almighty to justify his beliefs. He viewed himself a God’s messenger, just as Muhammad did. The appeal to God in either one is entirely beside the point. The point is the substance of the worldview. If what a man believes is terrible, then he is a terrible person. If he does not wish to be terrible, then he must give up his terribleness.
As for the argument that most Muslims do not perpetrate violence, this is irrelevant; one need not wait for someone to commit an act of violence to find his expressed beliefs morally reprehensible. The violent ones are, after all, the tip of the spear of a hateful ideology.
To be sure, opposing Nazism does not require denying Nazis their civil liberties. We can defend someone’s right to hold and express abhorrent beliefs without respecting those beliefs or those who hold them. This is one of the values of a free society over against an authoritarian or theocratic one. But, as I have explained on this platform, tolerance does not require moral neutrality toward intolerance.
Therefore, at the same time that we respect a man’s civil right to hold a disagreeable opinion, we restrict in some fashion his ability to assume political office to impose his worldview on the rest of us. One will get widespread agreement that we should not allow Nazis to hold political office (leaving the specifics of how we accomplish that to one side for now). Yet if one suggests that we should now we allow Muslims to assume office he will be met with condemnation. When I raise concern about the Grand Mufti of New York, or the incoming Muslim Senator, I risk being accused of bigotry. Some have already accused me of it.
The bottomline is that no ideology—secular or religious—is exempt from scrutiny simply because it is deeply embedded in someone’s identity. And no individual who subscribes to hateful ideology is entitled to not hear criticism of him. No special pleading can be allowed to open the political system to hateful and authoritarian ideology.
It is wrong to suppress speech critical of Islam not merely on free speech grounds; suppressing anti-Muslim speech disarms a population from resisting Islamization, in the same way that suppressing speech critical of Nazism makes the spread of that terrible ideology easier. Suppressing the speech of the anti-Nazi bigot suggests that those doing the policing are assisting Nazis in the promulgation of their worldview. What reasonable person would want to stand accused of enabling Nazism?
I was inspired to write this essay because a user on X disliked my anti-Muslim bigotry and challenged me to a live debate to defend my position. I declined because I do not take the man seriously. This upset the man and he told me he was curating all my anti-Muslim posts to present to my employer. I told he need not do that because I am not deleting anything I have written one the matter.
It’s wouldn’t be the first time a person who did not like my opinions presented them to my employer (2024 trans controversy being the lasted incident). I will stand my ground. I live in a free country, and I am prepared to defend my right to freely express my opinions. I am also devoted to defending Western Civilization from the peril of Islam. While I remain a free man, I will say what I will about the things that matter to me—and defend my right to do so to the hilt.
In these discussions, grasping for straws, those who would have been shut up about Islam, tell me that Islamophobia is the same as antisemitism. The attempt is to accuse me of a double standard. But the attempt rests on a false equivalency. It confuses ethnicity with religious belief. A Jew can be an atheist. Indeed, only one in four Jews subscribes to Judaism. Only half of Jews believe in a higher power. Jew is not a religious orientation. It is an inherited ethnicity category. A man is born a Jew. The gentile may convert to Judaism, but this does not make him a Jew in the ethnic sense.
A Muslim, by contrast, cannot be an atheist because to be a Muslim is to subscribe to Islam. If a man rejects Islam, he is by definition not a Muslim. If he never believes, he is an infidel. If he used to be believe, he is an apostate. This is because Muslims make an ethnicity no more than Christians make an ethnicity. Nor does Nazi comprise an ethnic category. National Socialism is a militant political ideology—like Islam is. And like Nazism, Muslims are ambitious; they wish to remake the world.
For the record, I would never report an antisemite to his employer. I would condemn him where he stands.
The ecumenical type will tell me that Muslims can peacefully co-exist with Christians, Jews, and other religions. But history shows us that this has never been the case. Furthermore, the desire for peaceful coexistence is not what Muslims tell us. The Qur’an and the Hadith teach that Christians and Jews are to be conquered and subordinated. Once conquered, those of other faiths must pay the jizyah, a tax on non-Muslims, paid in exchange for recognition as a dhimmis, in which the non-Muslim receives state protection and religious autonomy under Muslim sovereignty. The Hadith allows for two alternatives, neither of which is attractive: convert to Islam or be killed.
If you note that islam sounds like a mafia, you will be told that Muslim countries no longer do this. But that is only in the current situation where no global caliphate exists. One of the reasons for resisting Islam, aside from its antisemitism, homophobia, and misogyny, is to prevent the establishment of a world caliphate, in which all the horrors of Islam will be manifested. Paying the jizyah will not be the worst that will happen to you.
Speaking of Christians, it would be almost as surprising to be accused of Christophobia as being policed for anti-Nazi bigotry. While progressives find criticism of Islam and Muslims to be a punishable offense, they are not often moved to condemn anti-Christian rhetoric. Christians are routinely condemned for expressing their faith in public, and ridiculing Christians is met not with horror but laughter. Indeed, the attempt to purge Western language of expressions of Christian faith and diminish the presence of Christians in the public square is decades-long. Many if not most Christians take this in stride. In this regard (and many others) they are very different than Muslims and their defenders.
Note the recent controversy over comedian Arynne Wexler’s recent bit about Zohran Mamdani (where the Grand Mufti of New York line was coined) at Commentary Magazine’s annual fundraising roast. The video of Wexler’s set is approaching 12 million views and currently enjoys 75 thousand likes on X. Her detractors have flooded X with posts condemning her, with many asking if those appreciating such humor would have the same attitude if the jokes had been about Christians or Jews—as if Christians and Jews haven’t been the butt of jokes for decades. Muslims and progressives are a humorless bunch.
We all know that, had Wexler’s jokes came at the expense of those religions, there would be no controversy. Nor would the video of her set enjoy so many views and likes. Perhaps this is what troubles the Islamophiles so much; the bubble they live in has left them unaware that expressions branded as anti-Muslim have broken out of their containment field. The world is waking up. This comes with its own danger. With the rise in anti-Muslim sentiment we can expect more Muslim violence. It will get a lot uglier before we win. And, if we lose, it will get a lot uglier than that.

